Convergent Validity Between Epoch-Based activPAL and ActiGraph Methods for Measuring Moderate to Vigorous Physical Activity in Youth and Adults

Creator(s)

Adrian Ortega, Children's Mercy Kansas City
Bethany Forseth, Children's Mercy Kansas CityFollow
Paul R. Hibbing, Children's Mercy Kansas City
Chelsea Steel, Children's Mercy HospitalFollow
Jordan A. Carlson, Children's Mercy HospitalFollow

Document Type

Article

Publication Date

2023

Identifier

DOI: 10.1123/jmpb.2022-0013

Abstract

Purpose: We investigated convergent validity of commonly used ActiGraph scoring methods with various activPAL scoring methods in youth and adults. Methods: Youth and adults wore an ActiGraph and activPAL simultaneously for 1–3 days. We compared moderate to vigorous physical activity (MVPA) estimates from the ActiGraph Evenson 15-s (youth) and Freedson 60-s (adult) cut-point scoring methods and four activPAL scoring methods based on metabolic equivalents (METs), step counts, vertical axis counts, and vector magnitude counts. All activPAL methods were applied to 15-s epochs for youth and 60-s epochs for adults, and the METs method was also applied to 1-s epochs. Epoch-level agreement was examined with classification tests (sensitivity, positive predictive value, and F1) using the ActiGraph methods as the referent. Day-level agreement was examined using tests of mean error, mean absolute error, and Spearman correlations. Results: Relative to ActiGraph methods, which indicated a mean MVPA of 41 min/day for youth and 24 min/day for adults, the activPAL METs method applied to 15-s epochs in youth and 60-s epochs in adults yielded the most comparable estimates of MVPA. Daily MVPA estimated from all other activPAL scoring methods generally had poor agreement with ActiGraph methods in youth and adults. Conclusion: When using the same epoch lengths between monitors, MVPA estimation via the activPAL METs scoring method appears to have good comparability to ActiGraph cut points at the group-level and moderate comparability at the individual-level in youth and adults. When using this scoring method, the activPAL appears to be appropriate for measuring daily minutes of MVPA in youth and adults.

Journal Title

Journal for the Measurement of Physical Behaviour

Volume

6

Issue

2

First Page

115

Last Page

123

Recommended Citation

Ortega A, Forseth B, Hibbing PR, Steel C, Carlson JA. Convergent Validity Between Epoch-Based activPAL and ActiGraph Methods for Measuring Moderate to Vigorous Physical Activity in Youth and Adults. Journal for the Measurement of Physical Behaviour. 2023;6(2):115-123. doi:10.1123/jmpb.2022-0013